What college team first scored on the two point conversion Point After Touchdown (PAT) Return

Yesterday in the NFL the New Orleans Saints were the first NFL team to take advantage of a new rule: They blocked an extra point, now a 33 yard “feat” instead of a 20 yarder, (which frankly has made a huge difference in the number of kicks made and teams going for two point conversions on the (PAT) point after touchdown), and returned it for two points.

The ability to go for two points after scoring a touchdown is relatively new, but for a team to score a 2 point “defensive” try is new this year and essentially was completed when the Carolina Panthers scored a touchdown and were attempting a PAT (kick) to tie the game. New Orleans’ Kevin Williams blocked Graham Gano’s extra point then Stephone Anthony took it back the other way. This is the first two pointer in NFL history.

Nothing newsworthy above, or something you will not find in any sports section or web site today…. BUT…here is my trivia question. College football has had this rule since 1988….when was the first time it happened at the collegiate level? Even if you are a huge college football fan, you will never get this answer, unless you were there.

I was:

Unlike the NFL (week 13), it happened in the first game of the season, and in one of the first games played that early September Saturday. I was a first year SID (Sports Information Director) at Iona College and the Gaels were playing their nemesis, the St. John’s Redmen (now Red Storm). (As an aside, sadly, both of these programs have dropped football).  Iona had built a strong program under former New Rochelle legend (and now Ramapo AD) Harold Crocker and was ready to take the next step. The game was played at Mount Vernon’s Memorial Stadium, which was long past its heyday, if it ever had one. If you have ever watched the Iona Prep vs. New Rochelle Thanksgiving Day high school football game on Channel 11 back in the day, this was the place they played. To put it nicely, the place was a dump. But Iona, at the time, had no field on campus—this was their home field, miles away from the New Rochelle campus.

The game was televised by MSG Network, which was fairly new, with the talent being a rising star by the name of Bob Papa (no need to explain what a fine broadcaster and career he has had) and I am struggling to remember who the analyst was; definitely a former NFL player, perhaps Dave Jennings or Wesley Walker? (Anyone want to help me with that? I didn’t keep my game notes!)

In any case, the game was a barn burner–a very good game, and Iona scored a late TD to tie the game. The extra point was blocked and the ball lay perilously on the ground with neither team particularly interested in pursuing it. Having played football all of their lives, why would they? Everyone has reacted to this play as being a dead ball since the beginning of football! In the press box we immediately announced to the writers and broadcast team that it was a “live ball.”

The ball finally came to rest by the Iona sideline and with the Gael coaches trying to implore their players on the field (without making it too obvious) to come over and fall on it. The St. Johns coaches were screaming from the far sideline to their players and some fans were buzzing in the stands….finally one of the Redmen players picked it up and began to sprint (about) 86 yards toward the Iona end zone,  a couple of Iona players gave chase but to no avail; the first two point conversion return had been scored in the history of the game.

For Iona, it was not just being on the wrong side of a trivia question, it also lost the game 26-24, yes, by the very two points that were scored on the first ever two point return.

So, if you ever win a drink because of this, make it a double, and give me a call!



  1. Hello Dave
    My name is Bob Dillulio and I just saw your post.
    I happened to be the one #13 who ran the Iona kick return back 98yds ? At the time that was a school record.
    My regret was I was suppose to be the one holding for the extra point but went crazy with the post TD excitement that I didn’t hold for the extra point.
    I knew the new rule and would have caught the returner from St. John’s.
    Bruce Beck was Bob Papa co announcer later in the year for our sports channel game that was televised against CW Post so he might have done the stJohns game as well.
    Who new what great announcers were doing the game back in 1988.


      1. Wow…you give me way too much credit…unless you are pulling my leg and know or…don’t know if it has ever happened in the NAIA, and I ONLY knew Iona because I was there… but here is a guy who will know….let me know!

        Lynn Meredith
        VP for Marketing & Communications
        Public and media relations, marketing and branding i


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s